Echo smart pen by Livescribe

Several of my colleagues have recently recommended that I take a serious look at the “smart pen” products produced by a company called Livescribe.  Essentially they manufacture and sell a pen that not only digitizes what you write (on special paper) but also records the corresponding audio that might be present when the pen was in use.  These notes can be stored on a computer so you can refer back to the information at a later time.  Obviously there are some easy use cases that come to mind for students, lawyers, or general business professionals who spend 90% of their days in meetings (i.e., me).  Given my background in technology I had heard of the company and was familiar with their Pulse device that was released in 2007 but was a bit concerned that the company’s flagship product had not received a refresh in nearly three years.

Worry no more.  Earlier this month Livescribe released the Echo which is essentially a major performance upgrade from the Pulse and improves the form-factor considerably.  In addition they’ve standardized the connectors used by the device so you don’t need to lug a docking station around with you to sync the pen with your computer.  That said, I’ve placed my order with and am hoping to have the device in hand later this week.

Stay posted.

Update (08-Aug): I received my Echo pen on Friday and despite struggling to get either my laptop or desktop PCs – both of which run Windows 7 – I was eventually able to begin using my new device.  Regarding the basic functionality (recording and playback of synchronized notes and audio), it essentially works as advertised.  I have yet to subject it to a full day of meetings and note taking, so we will see how it fares this week.  One item I did notice is that the actual ballpoint pen is a bit “scratchy” and isn’t nearly as smooth as a generic pen of this nature would perform.

Update (13-Aug): After using the Echo pen for just one day I decided to replace it.  Whenever I tried to transfer notes to my computer that were written somewhat legibly on paper, they transfered over looking like a page full of scribble.  Below is an excerpt from one of my attempts:

Additionally the pen’s operating system seemed to hang on occasion and would require me to power it on and off before it would respond to commands.

I received my replacement yesterday and I’m having another go at it today.

Update (25-Aug): Despite receiving a replacement pen from and upgrading the OS on the pen, it still does not work as advertised.  The handwriting recording functionality seems to struggle with my vertical pen strokes and records only about 50% of those marks.  I’ve tried holding the pen in several different ways (including several that are quite uncomfortable) and none seem to help address the issue.  That said, the audio recording capabilities are quite good but that does not do much to compensate for the other problems.  Alas, as of today I have returned my Echo smart pen and am awaiting my refund.

5 thoughts on “Echo smart pen by Livescribe

  1. Pingback: Post 500: Top posts for week ending 07-Aug and for all time | The Road Not Taken

  2. Pingback: Top posts for week ending 21-Aug | The Road Not Taken

  3. I’ve been using my Echo Smartpen for graduate school for two weeks now, for notes for classes and meetings with my professors. I have not had any problems with it it, and it is wonderful to have the copies of both the audio of the session and the visual of my notes and load them onto the laptop. I especially like being able to tap in a particular section of my page to get the audio for that section — it makes it very easy to navigate to the right spot in recording. The only problems I have had are when I forget to recharge it or, when in a lecture, forgot to turn the pen on and/or tap Record. Then I get my notes, but no audio or visual recording. I find the Echo very easy to use and a fantastic resource for anyone attending lectures, meetings, or any other even where a recording would be useful. I just ordered eight more notebooks. I plan to use this as my primary note-taking tool.

    • Thanks for the post. I have a colleague that loves his Pulse and couldn’t believe that I returned the Echo. Maybe it was the way I was holding it, perhaps it was the speed or nature of my handwriting – either way the darn thing wouldn’t work.

Comments are closed.